Tuesday, 15 April 2014

From Australia to Trinidad & Tobago

There has been a growing importance in linking production and consumption through the study of commodity chains. In recent years, there has been an increasing interest in bringing together the analysis of different sites including production, distribution, retailing, design, advertising, marketing and final consumption. Here, the meaning of different sites along the trade and the flow of goods can be traced (Leslie and Reimer 1999, 401-402). According to Harvey’s “Class relation, social justice and the politics of difference” from the 1993 publication in Identity and the Politics of Location (quoted in Hartwick 2000) it is important for a politically responsible person to know about and respond to all the people who put breakfast on our table, even though market exchanges hide from us the condition of life of the producers. We are therefore connected to people in distant places on a daily basis through consumption. Hartwick (2000) further points out that exploration of the commodity chain brings one to the realization that the contrasting ends of production and consumption are occupied by real people and their daily struggles. While political activism has caused consumer goods to have cruelty-free and environmentally-friendly labels, the same degree of connectedness has not been established between consumers and people who work on that land in production.

Yellowtail wine is enjoyed in Trinidad and Tobago for many different occasions and leisure, however, do people stop to think about where it comes from and who is involved in farming and harvesting these grapes? Will people’s perception and choices change if they knew the retail and distribution channels or is the value of consuming this wine about prestige, status, symbolism and image? Hartwick (2000) has found that people consume based on image rather than need. This blog is intended to trace yellowtail wine from the bottle in our stores through various channels back to the grape.

From bottle to grape or grape to bottle?

Going into my favourite liquor store in Maraval where they stock so many different varieties of wines and champagnes, I was sure they were going to narrate the journey of the yellowtail wine from crop to store. This perception I held because so much insight is given when they are asked for assistance in pairing wine tastes and the brackishness or sweetness of certain flavours on the palette and which wine is suitable for different occasions etc. This knowledge I realized is just enough to effectively market and sell the various wine flavours to consumers but does not entail production. I was met with the harsh reality when I told the manager that I was trying to trace this bottle of wine from the store back to its origins. His response was, “I don’t know where it comes from, we buy from Hadco Limited because they supply wines in Trinidad. You can try asking them but I doubt you will get that information.” When Hadco Limited was contacted the following day, I was blatantly told that if the information is not on their website, then they are not allowed to divulge such details. It was alarming to discover how secret the channels of distribution for this commodity are being kept.

Attempting to now trace the wine from the grape to the bottle and being limited to online research, it was found that this wine has made quite a long journey to get to our island. Yellowtail wine originates from a humble place called Yenda in the Riverina region of New South Wales, Australia. Here, Filippo and Maria Casella emigrated from Sicily to Australia in 1957 where they labored as itinerant workers in the north Queensland cane fields and New South Wales fruit fields (Dufour and Steane 2010). They brought with them three generations of wine making skills from the old world, Italy and so decided to pursue their dream after saving of buying a sixteen (16) hectare farm of wine grapes in 1965.
Filippo and Maria Casella in their wine grape farm
 

According to Dufour and Steane (2010), they managed to secure relatively inexpensive but good quality grapes since this region is one of Australia’s most efficient wine producing regions. Grape growing then became wine making and wine making required a winery and so in 1969, their winery was established. They combined the wines with their blends and packaged the end result under their own label. John Casella, one of Filippo’s sons relieved his aging parents from wine making in 1994 and started expanding the winery with an aim to phase out bulk wine production and export a branded wine to various destinations. Therefore, the domestic market was forgone and Australians were not given access to the wine which was developed for export. They aimed at success in the American market and in order to cater to their tastes, the Casella’s looked for the most popular styles of wine in the American market that consumers wanted more of. What they discovered was that people favoured a fruit-forward taste suitable for any occasion as opposed to the complications of food pairings and specific tastes at the time. It therefore catered for a segment of young and price sensitive new wine amateurs.

Finding a distributor in the USA proved to be a difficult task, however, after two years with the help of the Australian Trade Commission Offices (AUSTRADE), they were paired with WJ Deutsch and Sons where the US importer was given 50 percent equity in the then unlabeled wine. Shortly after, the label ‘yellowtail’ was bought in 2000 and the symbol of the kangaroo was chosen to easily let the consumer know where the wine originated given that the kangaroo is synonymous with Australia. This branded wine was shipped for the first time to the USA in 2001 and though they targeted to sell 25000 cases, one million cases were actually sold in the first year (Dufour and Steane 2010). Politics, apart from taste contributed to the success of the brand in America because of Australian support to America’s intervention of Afghanistan as opposed to the French after the September 11 attack on the World Trade Center. Once the wine reached the USA, distribution to Trinidad and Tobago was easy as WJ Deutsch and Sons sold the brand to Hadco Limited, which is a major distributor of wine, spirits, food, beverages, among other things in Trinidad. From Hadco, it was purchased by the liquor store in Maraval.


Social and Environmental Conditions of Wine grapes growth in Yenda

There are certain grape-growing attributes that favour the Riverina region to be the highest producing wine grapes region in in Australia. Today, the Casella vineyard in the Carramar Estate, occupies 220 hectares where one-third of the yellow tail wines are produced from these grapes. The rest of wine grapes are bought from the Riverina region from other farmers. The geology of the Riverina area where Yenda is located is red-brown earth which has loamy surface horizon (10-35cm deep) followed by a reddish-brown clay which contains lime at a depth of 70 cm. Vines can only be grown with irrigation in this region. Key elements for successful wine grapes are long hours of sunshine and reliable supply of water. The annual rainfall of 406 mm is spread evenly throughout the year. High evaporation, low relative humidity, ample sunshine, high solar radiation and a high growing season temperature of 23.8ºC in January are all characteristics of summer. Autumn temperatures are 14.3ºC with humidity at 77 percent. The grapes for my favourite wine, the cabernet sauvignon are harvested in this time.

The viticulture or grapes cultivation in this region is uniformed. Vines are 1.5 metres high on a single or double foliage wire. Row width is usually 3.5 metres with the vine spacing 2 to 3 metres producing a density of 1200 to 1500 vines per hectare.
Image of wine grapes width and spacing
 

Yields have increased throughout the years because of better clones becoming available, selection of virus-free material, the use of fertilisers and the introduction of the Patterson under-vine plough. Mechanical harvesting and pruning have allowed vineyards to become larger with economies of scale becoming more apparent. Night harvesting to produce cooler fruit, machine pruning and under-vine and drip irrigation all increased efficiency of production and yield (Riverina Wine Industry 2007).

While specific information on storage and transportation of this wine could not be accessed, it is general knowledge that wines have to be stored at particular temperatures and at certain angles even when transporting by truck from the winery and from the port by boat. The aging of wine also produces different tastes. No information was available about the conditions under which people work when planting and harvesting in this region. However, the Carramar estate, boasts of practicing sustainable agriculture by recycling 100 percent of waste water from the Casella winery at their Mt Bingar Reclamation Facility. It has the capacity to recycle about 400 million litres of water per year and is chemical free and environmentally friendly. The Casellas plan to irrigate farms close to the winery with this water. The storage capacity of wine on their estate is 200 million litres in huge stainless steel storage tanks and they also have the fastest bottling machinery of 20 000 bottles per hour.
Image of stainless steel storage tanks
 

Image of yellowtail bottling line
 
 
How has this commodity been made meaningful to this region and our society?

To explore this aspect of the commodity chain, we must first rehash the history of how wine penetrated our society. According to the New York Times (2007) wine making is as old as civilization itself as the earliest cultivation and fermentation of grapes dates back to 6000 B.C. in the ancient Middle-East. The Egyptians recorded wine harvests on their tombs and bottles of wine were even buried with pharaohs so that they could entertain in the afterlife. Wine was also considered a drink of the elite in ancient Greece. However, when Rome conquered Greece in 146 B.C., they took wine as their own and created their own God, Bacchus. Wine became popular in society as wine bars were set up along the streets of Roman cities and as the empire and troops expanded across Europe, grapevines were planted in modern day France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, Spain and some Central European nations. As the Roman Empire adopted the Catholic Church and Christianity, wine became an integral part of the sacrament. Therefore, as the Catholic Church grew across Europe, wine grew with it. In 1492, when the Spanish conquistadors ventured into the New World, wine was brought into South America and the Caribbean. In 1554, Chile’s first winery was established by the Spanish and then it spread to Argentina (Vinepair 2014).

The history of wine highlighted above, shows how it entered our region and with European colonization for centuries, it is safe to assume that wine consumption was associated with the upper classes in colonial times as Catholicism was also the dominant religion. Therefore, wine consumption was initially an elite and/or religious culture. Presently however, wine is seen as just another alcoholic beverage that complements our society’s culture of ‘liming.’ Increasingly, globalization of wine is also affecting our consumption as we have adopted food and beverage preferences from the US as seen on television and in our supermarkets. The Trinidad Express Newspaper (2011) highlights that the US is becoming a nation that embraces food culture and so as more persons are embracing different meals, they wish to pair them with different wine flavours. We have also adopted a similar culture in terms of food and recreation. Wine also appeals to health fanatics like me where it is considered a low calorie alcoholic beverage and also the red wine has been found to have health benefits when consumed in moderation. The Guardian Newspaper (2012) highlighted that the red skin grapes used to make red wine reduces the risk of diabetes, improves cardio-vascular function by reducing clotting and may promote anti-cancer activity. Therefore, as many people become more health conscious in our society, wine seems to be a suitable option when consuming alcohol.

In conclusion, there are certain aspects of the commodity chain that are not accessible to the consumer, making the social link between consumer and producer very difficult. This proves the point of Hartwick (2000) that companies wish for consumers to buy the label and the image as opposed to seeing the moral side of things or the struggles endured by people in the agricultural fields. It is evident from this commodity chain that yellowtail wine has successfully penetrated our markets because of our import link to the USA and it has become an integral part of wine consumption in our society. 


Reference List

·         Casella Wines. 2008. “Casella Wines.” Accessed April 11, 2014. http://www.casellawines.com/home

·         Dufour, Y., and Peter Steane. 2010. “Building a good solid family wine business: Casella Wines.” International Journal of Wine Business Research 22 (2): 122-132. Accessed April 10, 2014. http://www.deepdyve.com/lp/emerald/building-a-good-solid-family-wine-business-casella-wines-WEUHgU4EbB/7

·         Hartwick, E. R. 2000. “Towards a geographical politics of consumption.” Environment and Planning A 2000 (32): 1177-1192.

·         Leslie, D., and Suzanne Reimer. 1999. “Spatializing commodity chains.” Progress in Human Geography 23 (3): 401-420.


·         The New York Times. 2007. “A Brief History of Wine.” Accessed April 11, 2014. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/05/timestopics/topics-winehistory.html?_r=1&

·         The Trinidad Guardian Newspaper. 2012. “The health benefits of drinking wine.” Accessed April 11, 2014. http://www.guardian.co.tt/lifestyle/2012-07-13/health-benefits-drinking-red-wine

·         The Trinidad Express Newspapers. 2011. “Ooh la la! US wine sales top France.” Accessed April 10, 2014. http://www.trinidadexpress.com/business-magazine/Ooh_la_la__US_wine_sales_top_France-118480614.html 

·         Riverina Wine Industry. 2007. “Riverina Wine Industry Background Information.” Accessed April 10, 2014. http://www.riverina-winemakers.org.au/riverinahistory.pdf

·         Vinepair. 2014. “How Wine Colonized the World.” Accessed April 11, 2014. http://vinepair.com/wine-colonized-world-wine-history/#24